Monday, December 21, 2009

Vitamin A

Vitamin A - what is it good for in bath & body products? It's an oil soluble molecule that can improve skin barrier function, increase cell proliferation, increase thickening of the skin, and increase collagen production. It can also help increase skin's water retention, and it may be effective in preventing, retarding, or restoring changes associated with the aging process. It is also effective in wound healing. It is the most abundant vitamin in our skin (in the form of ester retinyl palmitate), which is hydrolyzed to form Vitamin A, which is then oxidized to produce retinoic acid (the active form).

There are several forms of Vitamin A - the retinoids - we can use in bath and body products - retinol, retinyl esters (retinyl propionate, retinyl acetate, retinyl palmitate), and retinaldehyde. Each of these is ultimately converted into trans-retinoic acid, the active form of Vitamin A in our skin, but the retinyl esters are less effective than retinol, and are less stable in our products. We can find retinoic acid (tretinoin) in some of our oils.

Vitamin A is measured in International Units or IU. An IU of Vitamin A equals 0.3 µg retinol, 0.34 µg Vitamin A acetate, or 0.55 µg Vitamin A palmitate. It is classified as a drug by the FDA, so please don't make any claims about including Vitamin A in your products!

Retinyl palmitate specifically has been found to help maintain skin's barrier properties by stimulating the epidermal cells to produce glycolipids, which are important for the formation of the intercellular lipid lamellar structure in skin.

In a study on hairless mice, a cream with 0.1% Vitamin A administered over 14 days increased collagen content of the mice's skins by 88%. 0.5% Vitamin A palmitate uncreased the collagen content by 10%. And in a study on rats, 10 µg Vitamin A acetate suspended in 0.2 ml water lead to an increase in cell proliferation four hours after usage. In a study on human volunteers, aged 40 to 60, the application of Vitamin A palmitate to the temples showed an increase in skin thickness of 14% in two weeks and 22% over 6 weeks. Unfortunately, once you stop using products with Vitamin A, you return to your previous pre-Vitamin A skin condition. (But this is the case for most things - stop using it, you don't get the benefits!)

Retinol is the most effective form of Vitamin A in bath and body products. The effects of retinol usage can be very quick - epidermal thickening can in a matter of a few hours, take place in days, reduction of fine lines in a couple of weeks, and reduction of wrinkles in weeks to months. And you only need to use 1%!

Vitamin A is touted as a great ingredient for after sun exposure. Our blood levels of Vitamin A decrease when we are exposed to the sun for a short period of time, and the levels keep dropping the longer we stay in the sun. (Isn't that fascinating? No, seriously. Why have I never heard of this before?) A similar effect is noticed in our skin. So by adding Vitamin A to our products (or using oils high in the retinoids or ß-carotene) we can increase the Vitamin A content of our skin. Interestingly enough, scienticians still aren't sure of the exact mechanism by which Vitamin A actually works on sun exposed or photo-aged skin!

Why do we care about how much Vitamin A is in our skin? Vitamin A diminishes the appearance of fine lines due to increased skin cell production, which leads to increased epidermal thickness. The thicker our skin, the less likely we are to see fine lines!

It increases the production of epidermal ground substance (glycosaminoglycans or GAGs), which bind water in the skin. This results in increased hydration of skin and moisture retention. But we don't want too much GAGs in our skin, and Vitamin A inhibits production of too much ground substance! (Did that make sense? It increases the production but inhibits the production, both of which are good things?) The GAGs are required in our skin for normal collagen structure and function, but too much can lead to wrinkling in photo-damaged skin. (Shar pei dogs have too many GAGs, hence the wrinkled look!) Water retention is a great thing for skin - we want maximum moisturization!

It helps with wound healing by increasing the rate of cell proliferation so new cells can come to the surface of our skin quicker. And it helps with skin thickening in this way as well.

An increase in collagen production is a mighty fine thing indeed. As we age, we lose about 1% of our collage per year, which leads to reduced elasticity of our skin. With the reduction in the GAGs in our skin, we will appear less wrinkled.

Vitamin A is a good treatment for acne - it acts on the primary pre-acne lesion - and offers anti-inflammatory benefits. You'll often find Retinol prescribed for acne. (Although this makes me wonder why rose hip oil - with possible retinoic acid - is counter-indicated for acne. Hmm....)

Retinoids can be irritating to the skin! (Just ask someone like me who used Retinol prescription cream for years! When I cried or my eyes watered, it actually stung my cheeks!) Retinol and retinyl acetate are less irritating than retinoic acid, and retinyl palmitate is the least irritating. Use retinol at less than 1%. Retinaldehyde at 0.05% up to 1% - it's as irritating as retinol - but use retinyl palmitate at up to 2% in your products!

Most of the retinoids come from our oils in the form of carotenoids or pre-cursors to Vitamin A. So join me tomorrow for fun with carotenoids!


Mich said...

Hi Susan,

As usual, I enjoy reading your posts!

However, I think it's important to note one HUGE issue with Vitamin A: it can cause birth defects when taken (even in only moderately high doses) during pregnancy.

I know you are talking about topical applications (which are most likely safer than oral administration) but one should still consult their doctor if expecting. Better safe than sorry!

Susan Barclay-Nichols said...

And, as usual, you are the voice of reason! Thanks for the reminder, Mich! The whole point of making our own creations is to know what you're putting into them - hence all my research and posts - and we need to know the down sides as well as the benefits!

Carol said...

Which is better to use - Retinoic acid or Vitamin A Palmitate? Issues with solubility a concern?

Liz said...

Hi Susan - thanks for the post! Do you know of any natural oils that are Vitamin A rich? Thank you!

Susan Barclay-Nichols said...

Hi Liz! Check out the next post in the series on carotenoids to see which oils contain Vitamin A. As well, check out the individual posts on oils in the emollient section, or check out the carrier oil comparison chart or the exotic oil comparison chart.

Lisa said...

Hi Susan,

I love your blog. I learned a lot, and I also refer your blog for troubleshooting when I make my diy creams for personal use. Do you think it's safe to use Retinyl Palmitate? I want to use this ingredient in my creams to give me an extra boost, but I am hesitant on using this form of vitamin A. I have been reading how it can be carcinogenic if you come in contact with UV light. Then again, I see this ingredient in a lot of commercial creams.

HeidiL said...

Susan- where can I buy plain ole' Retinol? I can't find the stuff anywhere!

Thanks so much!

Magdalena Keating said...

Hi Susan,

I just bought myself a little bottle of Vitamin A and wanted to use it in a face cream, It is retinol Palmitate variety. Would I just add 2% in the oil phase? Are their any oils it should not be mixed with? Are there any other do's and dont's when making face cream out of vitamin A?

p.s I am so grateful for all your hard work on this blog!!!!

Magdalena Keating said...

oops I didnt select the email me with the follow up comment - so please when you respond can you respond to this link?
All the best


Susan Barclay-Nichols said...

Hi Magdalena! I think it's best to talk to your supplier as they will have suggestions for usage. I think it's okay to use 2% for the most part, but I'm not sure the specific details of your product. Keep it in an opaque container, and use an airless pump, if you can. Otherwise, just keep great notes about how your skin likes it so you can make sure it's doing you some good! Let me know how this turns out!

Renee Ng said...

Hi Susan,
I hv put my retinyl palmitate in the fridge but it's solidified into yellow clumps. After putting it at room temperature, it has still not thawed into liquid. Can I still use it? Will it affect its efficiency ? Thanks a lot.